Sunday, July 10, 2016
I Reads You Review - "DC COMICS PRESENTS: Batman"
DC COMICS – @DCComics
[This review was originally posted on Patreon.]
WRITERS: Geoff Johns; Len Wein
PENCILS: Carmine Infantino; Andy Kuhn
INKS: Joe Giella; Andy Kuhn
COLORS: Sno Cone; Bill Crabtree
LETTERS: Kurt Hathaway
MISC. ART: Carmine Infantino and Joe Giella
COVER: Adam Hughes
32pp, Color, $2.50 U.S., $3.85 CAN (September 2004)
Batman created by Bob Kane with Bill Finger
That late Julius “Julie” Schwartz (1915-2004) was known for his long association with DC Comics, where he was a longtime editor and guiding force. For a time, he was the primary editor of DC Comics' flagship franchises, Superman and Batman. Schwartz was also one of the earliest science fiction literary agents (being a co-founder of Solar Sales Service, a literary agency) and was basically one of the founders of early science fiction fandom.
After he died in February 2004, DC Comics created a short publishing event, the DC Comics Presents Specials, to celebrate Schwartz's contributions to the publisher. There were eight DC Comics Presents comic books in all, each one bearing a bullet-logo comprised of a cartoon portrait of Schwartz and emblazoned with the words, “A Julie Schwartz Tribute.”
Apparently, one of the hallmarks of Schwartz's editorial and creative vision was to conceive imaginative covers that would serve as springboards for DC Comics writers in need of story ideas. For these DC Comics Presents Specials, classic Schwartz “concept covers” were used to inspire new stories produced by creative teams that either worked with Schwartz or were inspired by his work. Each DC Comics Presents Special was a stand-alone comic book and contained two stories. Each comic book also featured a cover that re-interpreted, re-drew, or was inspired by a “concept cover.”
DC Comics Presents: Batman featured two stories inspired by the cover of Batman #183, which was drawn by Carmine Infantino (pencils) and Joe Giella (inks). DC Comics Presents: Batman also sports a modern take on Batman #183's cover, as drawn by Adam Hughes.
The first story is “Batman of Two Worlds” and is drawn by Infantino and Giella who drew the cover art for Batman #183. Written by Geoff Johns, the story finds Batman and Robin always bickering... until Batman kills Robin! No worries though, this Batman and Robin are fictional, the stars of a scripted television series based on the real Dynamic Duo. When the real Caped Crusaders start investigating this strange Bat-case, they find that everything is not what it seems.
Then, writer Len Wein and artist Andy Kuhn take Batman to television again in “The Ratings War!” The hottest show in Gotham City is “The Real Adventures of Batman and Robin.” In fact, this reality series is about the real Dynamic Duo, because its cameras capture Batman and Robin live and in action across Gotham City. And this show has taken bottom-feeding television station WGTM to the top of the ratings heap. So how does WGTM know when and where Batman and Robin will be in action?
DC Comics Presents: Batman made for pleasant reading. “Batman of Two Worlds” is the kind of simple, straight-forward story that would have fit right into almost any issue of 1960s era Batman or Detective Comics. In fact, the 1960s where when Carmine Infantino (with inker Joe Giella) was producing what would be a hugely-influential run of Batman comic book cover and interior art for both Batman and Detective Comics. However, Gardner Fox wrote many of the stories drawn by Infantino, and disappointingly, Geoff John's “Batman of Two Worlds” is a mere shadow of Gardner Fox's imaginative Batman tales of the 1960s.
Of the two stories, I prefer “The Ratings War!,” which I find truer to the spirit of Gardner Fox. Yet it has a timeless quality. The scenario for “The Rating War!” would be plausible (relatively speaking) in the 1960s. Obviously, this story probably makes more sense today, especially because the last three decades have seen countless reality TV series that follow “real-life” law enforcement on the job, in the courtroom, and behind the scenes.
I could be cynical and say that this Julie Schwartz tribute is as much about selling comic books as it is about remembering a DC Comics luminary, and I'd be right. There is a reason that when DC released this back in 2004, it threw around the names of the fan-favorite comics creators that were contributing to this “tribute.” That reason is sales.
Why did I buy the comic books that comprise this series? Well, I bought them because they are connected to Silver Age DC Comics. I will buy pastiches and tributes to Silver Age DC almost as quickly as I will buy actual reprints of Silver Age DC. And I like DC Comics Presents: Batman for what it reminds me of more than for what it actually is.
[This comic book contains an obituary of Julius Schwartz, “Softly: A Living Legend Passes,” written by Harlan Ellison with Brian M. Thomsen.]
Reviewed by Leroy Douressesaux a.k.a. "I Reads You"
The text is copyright © 2016 Leroy Douresseaux. All Rights Reserved. Contact this blog for reprint and syndication rights and fees.